How Christian City grew social media engagement 253% by telling the right stories

Christian City serves every generation. On any given day, its social media channels might highlight a heartwarming adoption, tell the story of a young adult finding their footing or showcase the senior community.
That range raises a question: How do you build one social media presence for an organization that serves so many audiences?
Choosing the right stories for the right audience
Christian City has no shortage of important stories, and our strategy requires knowing which stories to tell, where to tell them and who they need to reach.
The Wilbert Group works closely with Christian City’s team to develop pre-determined content themes such as senior living, children and families, special events and staff features. From there, each message is tailored to the platform where it will run.
Tailoring one event for every platform
The Christmas Star Run is a good example. On LinkedIn, posts speak directly to companies about sponsorship opportunities. On Facebook and Instagram, the goal shifts to driving registration and attendance. It’s the same event, but each platform gets a different message for a different audience.
Letting performance guide the content
We keep a close eye on what performs and adjust our content strategy over time. Data so far this year led to two major shifts:
- Photography over busy graphics. Strong photos show what life at Christian City actually looks like.
- More short-form video. Video lets people tell their own stories in their own words.
For example, instead of a static post announcing a new leader, we produced a reel in which Rand Burton, Jr., Christian City’s new Director of Church Relations, introduced himself to the community directly.
The results
After one year of this approach, Christian City’s social media performance grew across the board:
- Impressions increased 65%.
- Engagements increased 253%.
- Post clicks increased 695%.
Reaching the right people
Social media success isn’t just about reaching more people. It’s about reaching the right people with content that gives them a reason to take the next step.